Nanny Bags

No surprise that California is the source of this Nanny State story.  AB 1998 would ban plastic single use bags from grocery stores and make the markets charge customers for paper bags if they forgot their reusable bags.  You can read a lot more about it here

This is the Nanny State mentality on Hyper-drive.  It is bad enough to ban plastic bags but to implement a charge for paper is the state playing favorites in a battle that should be fought in the marketplace.

Here are a few facts that sensible people could use to defeat the plastic bag ban:

  • Reusable bags are unhygienic.  What was spilled in them before you put them on the checkout conveyor.  You wouldn’t reuse ziplock bags
  • Charging for papers bags is a tax on the convenience shopper.  It will unfairly impact the poor who tend to be less organized.
  • What will we use to pick up dog poop and scoop cat litter if there are no more plastic bags?
  • The bags that consumers use represent less than 10% of the total packaging that end up in landfills.  The rest is boxes, cartons and plastic liners etc.

Note to Nanny State Legislators; “Government is a blunt instrument.  Don’t use it to micromanage people behavior.”


Discover more from Simon Burrow

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

4 thoughts on “Nanny Bags

  1. I reuse ziplock bags all the time – watch out for me.

    And if stores had no bags, period, shoppers would figure out very quickly what to do 🙂

    Marta

  2. About people adjusting to no bags. If there were no cars people would figure out other ways to get places. I’m not sure that is an argument for social engineering.

  3. We own probably 15 or so shopping bags. I am a 3-R kinda guy. Reduce reuse recycle. But I agree, the Nanny state shouldn’t force you to use them. If they want to get involved in shopping, force manufacturers to use less packaging.

  4. Kollin We own lots of reusable shopping also but almost never remember to take them into the market. It took me 20 years to get the seatbelt habit and I thought that was a good thing.

Comments are closed.